When you should use Manual CPC for running your healthcare ads

You’re going to want to use Manual CPC when running healthcare ads on Google if you are privacy-conscious, are willing to study your incremental lift, and don’t have the budget (or the desire) to work with a third-party partner to “anonymize” your conversion data being sent to Google.

I’m Jesse, and I’ve managed over 7-figures of healthcare ad spend on Google. I’ve used both automated bid strategies and manual bidding. And I’ve seen the pros and cons of each. In my opinion, a manual bid strategy is still likely the right choice for a healthcare practice advertising on Google in 2026 and going into 2027.

Please note that this is educational and not legal advice.

What Manual Bidding Gives You

With manual bidding you get the following advantages:

  • Simple account set up (in my opinion)

  • No tracking pixel (and its associated privacy risks, both current and potentially future)

  • No third-party vendors in between your own conversion data and Google (further reducing privacy risk, as well as reducing your spend on potentially expensive vendors who have to sign a BAA for HIPAA)

  • The option of setting up your own internal conversion tracking (if you want to measure certain actions, such as lead form submissions on your website

  • More predictable spend and web traffic on highly targeted and relevant search terms for your healthcare practice

I’ve spent six-figures on Manual CPC campaigns, and when they are used in a way that looks at correlation ($X spent on marketing vs Y new patient leads), they can be an effective driver of growth for a clinic.

However, here are the disadvantages:

  • Lack of direct tracking (unless you implement your own internal conversions) makes it impossible to know your exact cost per lead

  • Lack of tracking being fed into automated bid strategies. I’ll write more about that below

The lack of direct tracking feeding conversion data into Google’s algorithm means that you won’t be able to benefit from any automated bid strategies that are meant to drive targeted conversion actions. I’ve seen first-hand how large of a delta there can be when a manual bid strategy is put up against a automated bid strategy for optimizing a specific online action. The automated strategies are superior if your measure of success is a very specific and measureable conversion action.

Which bid strategy to use for a single location healthcare practice for new patient acquisition

In my experience, for a single-location practice, I would strongly recommend implementing a manual bid strategy for your new patient acquisition efforts. The gains in patient privacy are alone a worthwhile benefit. The lack of direct conversion measurement is also not necessarily as bad as it seems, since you can measure incremental lift in terms of new patient volumes once you start advertising.


The “track everything” crowd may be right in terms of driving absolute efficiency when it comes to your new patient acquisition cost, but the gains are marginal, and there can be a steep rise in privacy-compliance costs if you decide to go down that road. If your ad budgets are under $20,000 per month, it may not be worth it.

Related on the Copy for Originals site: HIPAA-compliant conversion tracking for Google Ads compares the ways a practice can track ads without sending patient data to Google, and Google Ads for lead generation sets out when Smart Bidding fits and when Manual CPC does.

Jesse Bastide

Google Ads solopreneur Conversion Copywriter. Let’s grow together. Feel free to reach out.

https://copyfororiginals.com
Next
Next

Why you might want manual control over your Google Ads (why use Manual CPC in 2026)